In years past, writers who found themselves in the unfortunate position of finding their work infringed upon would have only one course of action: to take the infringing party to federal court to pursue damages there. This often would require not only a massive time commitment, but the potential for a great expense in court fees, attorney fees, and damages.
In late December 2020 and as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021[1], the CASE Act (Copyright Alternative in Small-Claims Enforcement Act[2]) was signed into law. This new amendment to copyright law is an alternative for writers who have been infringed upon as it commissions a Copyright Claims Board (CCB) made up of three copyright officers specially appointed from the U.S. Copyright Office to hear certain small claim infringement cases. The new claims board is set to be established by no more than a year and a half from when the CASE Act was signed into law (or by June 2022).
The CCB will greatly reduce the costs of taking an infringement case to court (at the minimum, $100 and no more than the costs of filing a claim in federal district court). Writers or other copyright holders who wish to bring a claim before the CCB will be able to do so without the need for legal counsel, and the proceedings will be streamlined.
The CCB’s system will be a completely voluntary process, meaning that those who are defendants in an infringement claim will have the option to opt out of the process completely within 60 days of a filing. That said, one of the great incentives for a defendant to appear before the tribunal is that all damages are limited by design to a total of $30,000. In federal court, statuory damages can run up to $150,000 per instance of infringement, and additional damages could be awarded on top of that amount.
The CASE Act will provide an even playing field as the copyright holders will be required to have their work formally registered with the U.S. Copyright Office[3] prior to filing an infringement case before the CCB. Importantly, this requirement for copyright registration in infringement cases (brought to federal court) was recently underscored in the suit Fourth Estate Public Benefit Corporation v. Wall-Street.com[4].
The CASE Act was also designed to help prevent so-called copyright “trolls” from bringing frivolous claims, excessive counterclaims, and fraudulent defenses in front of the CCB. The tribunal would be empowered to penalize bad actors by setting limits on how many claims can be filed each year, awarding attorneys’ fees in extreme cases, and even dismissing all claims filed by abusers of the system.
The passage of the CASE Act and its CCB is significant to copyright law in the United States, and writers can take comfort in knowing that they will have an additional—and less expensive—recourse at their disposal should they find themselves infringed upon.
Mary Jo (“MJ”) Courchesne is the owner and principal consultant of Gryphon Publishing Consulting. A publishing veteran with more than 20 years of experience in trade, academic, and direct-response publishing, she has spent nearly two decades specializing in licensing, subsidiary rights, and permissions. MJ is a frequent and polished presenter on licensing and copyright. When it comes to intellectual property, she firmly believes that everyone from authors to publishers to corporations should know their rights. To that end, MJ instructed in the George Washington University’s Masters in Publishing program for 13 years, first for 11 years as adjunct professor for a course titled Editorial Content, Rights, and Permissions and subsequently as lecturer in a course on copyright. She currently serves on the Board of Experts for the National Association of Independent Writers and Editors and is a member of the Independent Book Publishers Association and the Society of Children’s Books Writers and Illustrators. MJ has also held memberships with other publishing organizations such as the American Society of Picture Professionals and Washington Publishers.
[1] https://rules.house.gov/sites/democrats.rules.house.gov/files/BILLS-116HR133SA-RCP-116-68.pdf see page 2544 for the start of the CASE Act in the Consolidated Appropriations Act omnibus bill
[2] original text: https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/2426/text
[3] https://copyright.gov/registration/
[4] https://www.scotusblog.com/2019/03/opinion-analysis-a-copyright-owner-cant-sue-for-infringement-before-the-register-has-processed-it
Kajli Prince (“Prince”) has over 20 years of experience in small business tax preparation; he is the office manager of H&R Block’s Sudley Manor Office in Manassas, Virginia. As a self-published author, Prince holds a special appreciation for NAIWE and its members. One of his passions is sharing relevant information with people and showing them how best to use it for their benefit. Prince is a small business owner of 25 years, and his specialties include emerging currencies (e.g., virtual/crypto currencies), information technology, intellectual property, and business administration.
Greg Smith is a writing coach, editor, and publisher. He founded the Agile Writer Workshop in 2011 with the mission of finding a method to help beginning writers complete a first draft in 6 months. The Agile Writer Method is based on the writings of experts in mythology, screenwriting, psychology, and project management. His seminars on the Agile Writer Method have informed and delighted thousands of writers, scholars, and university students. Agile Writer authors have written over 50 first draft novels and 10 published novels. Greg is a developmental editor for novelists and memoirists. He also coaches authors through the self-publishing maze. Greg runs the popular Agile Readers Book Club where new writers can get a beta read from a dozen or more readers.
Dana Sitar has been writing and editing for digital media since 2011, most recently as a copy editor for fintech and personal finance. She trains journalists, writers, and editors on writing for the web through sessions at the annual ACES editors’ conference, Utah Valley University, online courses, and private trainings. Dana has written about work and writing in digital media for publications including the New York Times, HuffPost, a column for Inc. Magazine, and dozens of writing and content marketing blogs. As a branded content editor for The Penny Hoarder, Dana managed a team of writers, editors, and social media experts to create multimedia branded content to help advertisers reach an audience of 12 million across platforms including social media, email, blog, and video.
Robert Moskowitz is an award-winning independent professional writer who has written and sold millions of words in just about every format over five decades. He instinctively sees the big pictures, breaks each one down into coherent slices, meaningfully prioritizes and sequences those slices, and then executes the tasks inherent in each slice in very productive ways. Put more simply, Robert knows how to succeed as an independent writer, covering all the bases from soliciting assignments to delivering polished work, from pricing jobs to budgeting and managing personal finances, from organizing a conducive office environment to establishing and following sensible guidelines regarding life, work, and productivity. Having done all this, and having paid attention to how he did it, Robert is now in a position to pass along what he knows to others.
Kristen Fischer is a copywriter and journalist living at the Jersey Shore. She worked as a reporter and copyeditor for Gannett before launching her full-time freelance business in 2005. Her work has been published in Parents, New Jersey Monthly, Prevention, Woman’s Day, SheKnows, and Healthline.
Ruth Thaler-Carter has been a full-time freelance writer, editor, proofreader, and desktop publisher for more than 30 years. She has been published locally, regionally, nationally, and internationally in, and does writing, editing, and proofreading for, publications, associations, nonprofits, websites, service firms, and businesses. She sold her first freelance articles when she was still in high school. Renowned as a skilled networker, Ruth is active in about a dozen professional associations, serving as a newsletter editor, webmaster, publication author, speaker/presenter, blogger, program host or planner, and chapter leader. In 2006, Ruth launched the Communication Central “Be a Better Freelancer” annual conference to help aspiring and established freelancers find greater success and connections with colleagues. Ruth is the owner and editor-in-chief of the An American Editor blog and received the Philip M. Stern Award of Washington (DC) Independent Writers for service to freelancers; the Writers and Books Big Pencil Award for teaching adults and contributions to the literary community; EFfie awards for writing, editing, and newsletters; and the APEX award for feature writing. She was also an IABC/DC Communicator of the Year.